首页 / 法律问答 / 好的,以下是我以人的口吻整理的说法: “关于烟绯逃税那事儿,我跟你说啊,她那么聪明,肯定有自己的门道。也许只是合理避税,或者对法律条款有独特的理解。毕竟,她可是个厉害的法律顾问,说不定只是在规则边缘游走呢!”

好的,以下是我以人的口吻整理的说法: “关于烟绯逃税那事儿,我跟你说啊,她那么聪明,肯定有自己的门道。也许只是合理避税,或者对法律条款有独特的理解。毕竟,她可是个厉害的法律顾问,说不定只是在规则边缘游走呢!”

商业律师 3 回答
Okay, so Yanfei's always yelling about writing off treasure hunting as "incidental gains," right? But is that even a thing? Well, it's complicated. Full disclosure: I'm not a tax expert, but I've done some accounting courses. Don't take this as actual advice! First off, "incidental gains" usually means revenue from a property while it's being developed. Think renting out offices before turning them into condos. It's not the main business, but it's still income. We need to talk about what revenue is, it's all the money BEFORE expenses. Revenue minus those expenses equals profit. Also, "gains" aren't about actively earning money; they're about value changes. Like, if you bought a lyre and its value went up later, that's a gain, but generally, you write off losses, not gains, because writing things off means lowering the amount you're taxed on. What Yanfei is talking about is closer to "non-operating income," which is income from stuff outside your main business. Like, if Wangsheng Funeral Parlor has a bank account that earns interest, that's non-operating income. Can you write it off? Nope. You usually have to declare all income, operating and non, to calculate your taxes. But here's where it gets weirder: Is treasure hunting even taxable? Some say it's a "windfall gain," like winning the lottery. Laws vary. In the US, you might have to pay taxes on the treasure's full value. In Australia, it's tax-free as a hobby but taxed if it's your business. China, where Liyue is based, might even consider it illegal! So, is treasure hunting a business? Most assume it's a hobby, but what about in Teyvat? And are we talking about employees or freelancers here? Characters in your party are employees, freelancers, owners, or just tagging along. The Traveler is in a weird spot, they do commissions for the Adventurer's Guild, and get hired by different cities. The Guild seems like a temp agency. It could be they're employees or independent contractors for the cities. But is treasure hunting part of the Traveler's business? It's up to them if they're freelancing. In the US, it's taxed anyway. In Australia, it depends on whether it's a real business. Are they actively seeking treasure, or just stumbling upon it? Are they getting hired to find treasure or is it for themselves? If they're employees, their employer has more say. Does the Guild or cities claim treasure found while working for them? It all comes down to contracts, which is Yanfei's thing. What about the rest of the party? What are their deals? How do they split and account for the treasure? Do kids like Klee pay taxes? In short, Yanfei's statement is messed up. She's using the wrong terms, mixing up "gains" and "non-operating income," and potentially miscategorizing treasure hunting. Plus, she's ignoring contracts, business structures, and employment status. And she's trying to write off a gain! So, trust Yanfei with your taxes? Maybe not. She needs a refresher on tax codes, even if she's a good investigator.
回答次数 (3)
凶哭你
# 3
Of special note is that Teyvat laws are different, as explained in the loading screen messages.

Also that the law code is written by a 20something beauty queen and is getting revised so much that only Yanfei is able to keep up. I don't wanna say someone that young can't write laws, but to put things in perspective, Ningguang is estimated to be about 25-28 years old, which is about the time most lawyers finish law school.

Also the guy who was basically running the show before that was so bad with money he literally forgot that buying things required having money on your person.

You've basically got the equivalent of someone who just finished law school writing all the finance laws for the richest country in the world, being overseen by a guy so rich he doesn't seem to grasp supply and demand principles, as well as scarcity. So for all we know the wording in the Liyue law codes really could be that wonky.

In general Hoyoverse tends to...fumble around...with details of things. Linguistics, geography, currency economics, scarcity, meteorology...really if it isn't cuisine or fireworks they seem to leave important bits out.
烈火狂涛
# 2
I love these high-effort worldbuilding-implications posts. Nice job OP!

I would venture that treasure-hunting is part of the Adventurer's Guild's business and that profit from finding treasure would therefore be taxable. Bennet, for instance, is an established member of the Guild but seems to perform treasure hunting almost exclusively.

But as you mention, the Traveler does a lot of types of work... I suppose it might depend on when they find the treasure? If they come across it while on a commission it's business and thus taxable, but during their own time or some paid-under-the-table side work it's not and whether or not it's taxable would depend on Liyue laws.

On that note, treasure and treasure hunting seems to be very common throughout Teyvat, and I've never known a state to pass up an opportunity to wring money from it's citizenry. I have to assume that the Liyue Qixing has some fairly rigorous laws on how to claim tax on treasure.

As to Yanfei trying to write off a gain... she's a very earnest believer in moral laws. If she thought a law was just, she would obey it even to her detriment. It's entirely likely she would find a way to pay more tax than legally required if she thought it was the moral thing to do.
P
PsychoJester
# 1
The main takeaway here is that Yanfei really shouldn't be trusted with filing those taxes at all. She may be a good investigator (Genshin Impact Forensic Accounting Game When) but oh boy she needs to re-learn her tax codes.


This would be pretty funny to pull on Yanfei that she breaks Tax Laws since she is heartless when it comes to laws being broken. She goes for maximum punishment even if it's overboard as she said in her Yanfei IV Dialogue Line:


Sometimes, the commercial disputes I handle don't end very pleasantly. The other party might win compensation way in excess of the damages, or pay damages far exceeding the costs... Such is the price of violating a contract. Some people say I'm pretty terrifying, others try to avoid me altogether, but I don't need to explain myself to anyone. Since the very beginning, the welfare of Liyue has been my primary concern!
Think about it — the origin of disputes can be traced back to the violation of contracts. People are a lot less likely to violate contracts when they see the fallout. Making sure that people realize the importance of contracts is a crucial part of my work.


Also I like how the fanbase is slowly accusing Yanfei of Tax Fraud since there was a comic where Ganyu caught Yanfei doing Tax Fraud and punished her for it. Though the comic is NSFW
北美法律通